17 April 2024 · 02:59:34 UTC

Black Silver Mine

Eagletail Mountains, Maricopa County, Arizona, USA

  • Training fall for MetDetect
  • Human-verified · Marc Fries
  • Meteorites recovered
Fireball (UTC)
2024-04-17 02:59:34 ± 5 s cameras and the GOES lightning mapper
Observed by
  • Fireball cameras
  • Casual video
  • Satellite
  • Witnesses
How it was observed
Radar searched
KYUX
Meteorites
Black Silver Mine (CK6) Meteoritical Bulletin entry
MetDetect
MetDetect RUN-42 training only, not in the headline numbers · radar KYUX

How it was observed

Fireball cameras are cameras built to record meteors, usually all-sky and calibrated. Casual video is footage or photos from cameras that were not (dash cams, doorbell and security cameras, phones); where a source does not say what kind of camera, it is listed as video of unknown type. Only what a source documents is listed; a missing label means nothing of that kind is documented, not that it did not exist.

Automated detection

MetDetect searched the KYUX radar around the fireball time. This is a training fall: there are fewer than 10 hand-identified radar cells on KYUX, too few for the headline numbers, so the fall only helps train MetDetect for the other falls (never for itself). Its answer contains none of the hand-identified cells.

  • 0of the 2 hand-identified cells on KYUX found
  • 2hand-identified cells missed
  • 18cells reported that were not identified by hand
  • 0%of the cells it reports were identified by hand (purity)
Map and height-against-time plot of the radar cells MetDetect found and the cells identified by hand
Each mark is one radar measurement cell on KYUX. Blue: found by MetDetect and identified by hand; orange squares: found only by MetDetect; green rings: identified by hand, missed by MetDetect. Left: positions (the arrow points to the radar); right: height against time after the fireball.

MetDetect RUN-42, 12 Nov 2026. Leave one fall out: every learned part was trained without the fall it is scored on. 30 of the 32 falls are the test set (dual-polarization radar, at least 10 hand-identified radar measurements on the radar searched); the other 2 are used for training only and are not in the headline numbers. The method was developed on these falls, so these are development results, not a blind test. This fall is not in the headline numbers. The hand identification is the reference these numbers are graded against.

Dark flight

After the fireball goes dark, meteorites fall freely through the wind. Each radar cell is flown down to the ground through the winds of that day; the coloured areas show where stones of each mass most likely landed, and the black line runs from light to heavy stones (solid where the radar traced it, dashed where extended). The map shows both: (a) from MetDetect's cells on KYUX, (b) from the radar cells identified by hand by Marc Fries on every NEXRAD radar labelled, in the same frame and colour scale. Each panel gives its search area for stones of 10 g and up (the 90% regions) and the recovered stones of 10 g and up inside it. Because MetDetect's first pick was not the debris, panel (a) shows where the stones of that other echo would land, if anywhere. It is not a search area for this fall.

Two dark-flight search maps side by side: from MetDetect's radar cells and from the radar cells identified by hand, with recovered meteorites as stars
Pixel propagation: each radar cell's fragments carried to the ground through the wind at the fireball time. Colours are fixed per mass decade (colour bar); for each decade from 10 g up the 50% region is filled and the 90% region dashed. The fall line is solid where the radar constrains it and dashed where extrapolated. Gold stars: recovered meteorites with published positions, sized by mass.

Pixel estimate, computed by P. Shober with MetDetect: winds from ERA5 (ECMWF), masses at the fall's assumed bulk density (on the colour bar). Preliminary: it does not fit the fireball itself, so the heavy end of the line is an extrapolation. Stars mark recovered meteorites; positions from Meteoritical Bulletin strewn-field list. They are drawn for comparison only and were never used to make the maps. Counted stones are those of 10 g and up, or of unpublished mass. Villages and rivers: © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Human identification

The radar signatures of this fall were identified by hand by Marc Fries. Read the original report (archived copy).

Meteorites

Nine stones, 456.4 g in all, were found from February 2025 within 1.6 by 0.35 km near the Black Silver Mine, the first (88 g) by Steve Arnold on 11 February 2025. The meteorite is a CK6 carbonaceous chondrite (Meteoritical Bulletin 114). NASA ARES lists this event as Clanton Well and reports martian meteorites from it; the Meteoritical Bulletin does not.

Publications

No papers on this fall yet that we know of.

Know of a paper or a recovered meteorite we missed? Tell us.

Meteorite quiz My asteroid